When I recently started a perfume company, people kept asking if I was going to open a storefront. When I said no, because I live in a cottage town where commerce really only runs from May-September, so I wouldn’t be able to make rent the rest of the year, they wanted to know how exactly I planned to sell perfume online. Because how are people supposed to buy a perfume without smelling it? Which is a perfectly reasonable question. And I would be like “I DON’T NOW YET OK?” but other people were doing it it, so how hard could it be, right?
Turns out it is hard. Not impossible, but genuinely difficult.
For obvious reasons, buying perfume blind is daunting. We’re used to walking into stores like Sephora and sniffing our way through everything—spritzing paper strips, spraying into the air, putting it on our skin. Then we walk away, sniff some more, come back later, and maybe buy something.
Or that’s how it’s supposed to work. Me? I walk in, all excited to smell new things, then, about eight scents in I start getting irrationally angry about how much I hate everything, harrumph my way out of the store, and buy nothing. Repeat next month. On the rare occasions that I do buy something, I almost always dislike it the next day. But now that I’m making perfume constantly, I don’t really wear anyone else’s scents anyway, so it’s a moot point.
Wait—where was I going with this?
Right… my point is that even in a situation where everything is smellable in person, it can still be hard to find what you’re looking for. The nose gets overwhelmed and confused between all the other scents in the air. And those coffee beans, by the way, are there for show. They don’t do jack to reset your nose. I’m not sure why that myth persists but you can safely ignore it. They don’t work. What does is sniffing your own skin in a spot where you’re not wearing any scent. That’s what perfumers actually do. Now you know a trick of the trade.
Why Perfume Feels Difficult to Buy Online
Smell is personal, invisible, and context-dependent. Your scent receptors are yours alone, similar to everyone else’s, but unique, like a snowflake. It’s fucking poetic, and it means you’re not necessarily going to like what everyone else likes.
It’s also probably that you can’t even smell some perfume notes. Everyone is supposedly anosmic to something, and some of the common things we’re anosmic to include certain musks, ambroxan, and sandalwood molecules. Others might be able to smell these things, but intensely dislike them. Like people who hate cilantro/coriander because it “tastes like soap.” That reaction is likely olfactory rather than gustatory. It smells like soap, rather than tastes like it. (There are those of us for whom that is a draw rather than a repellent. I like to eat things that taste like perfume or soap, like Thrills Gum. I love Thrills so much, I built a perfume around the idea of it. Meanwhile, I don’t usually like to wear things that smell like food. Because walking around stinking of cupcakes is gross.)
Some people think sandalwood smells like pickles, and most people don’t want to smell like pickles.
What you like is also shaped by your experience. Everything you’ve lived feeds into your taste in perfume: what your mother, father, or grandparents smelled like; the pipe someone smoked; the green hills where you spent childhood vacations; hot asphalt in summer; dripping popsicles; campfire smoke; cool sea breezes. All of it quietly trains your nose without you realizing it.
Moreover, your scent receptors don’t stay the same. They shift throughout the day, and over weeks and months, seasons and years. Hormones, stress, illness, medication, weather, sleep, aging, novelty, repetition—all of it changes how you perceive smell. A perfume that feels perfect today can be off-putting a year from now, not because the perfume changed, but because you did.
All of this makes committing to a bottle online feel like a gamble. Which, OK, it is. But there are ways to increase your chances of success which, of course I am going to share with you now, and which has nothing to do with me wanting you to buy my perfume online. Totally unrelated.
Know Perfume Terminology
There are a lot of buzzwords in fragrance. Knowing them helps you understand what something might smell like, and how perfumers and perfume critics/experts/whatever talk about perfume. For example:
Floral
Smells like flowers. This can mean anything from a literal rose or jasmine to a generalized floral impression that doesn’t resemble any specific plant. It’s a broad, imprecise category of “flowers.”
Citrus
Light, clean, bright smells—lemon, orange, grapefruit. Think: days and sometimes cleaning products when done badly.
Bergamot
This is so commonly listed among notes that it deserves its own list item. I can’t prove it but I believe “bergamot” is used as a catch-all to mean “citrus,” even in fragrances that contain no bergamot. Probably because it sounds more exotic than “lemon” and “orange.” It’s a common ingredient but not as common as perfume marketers would have you believe.
Fruity
Smells like fruit. This overlaps with citrus but also includes peach, apple, berries, and tropical notes, often rendered in ways that don’t resemble the real fruit very closely.
Sweet/Gourmand
Smells like sugar. This is a category, as well as an intensity setting that appears across many others. Gourmands smell like food, usually dessert—cookies, cupcakes, cake, spun sugar. Key ingredients are maltol and vanillin.
Green
Grassy, leafy, plant-like. Fresh plants, crushed stems, a meadow, the aforementioned grassy hills people remember from childhood vacations.
Woody
Smells like wood—sandalwood, cedarwood, and various materials that register as wood-like (iso e super, vertofix). Vetiver, patchouli, and oakmoss are often grouped here too, even though vetiver is a grass and the latter two are a shrub and a lichen.
Amber
Not amber the fossilized resin with bugs in it, and not the color. This is a fantasy accord made from sweet, resinous, animalic elements—usually vanillin and labdanum, sometimes benzoin and ambroxan. Confusingly, ambroxan smells warm and woody and nothing like the vanillin/labdanum combination, despite being the only ingredient whose name resembles the word “amber.” Ambergris is also often called “amber,” though it’s rarely used because it’s whale poop and it costs a bajillion dollars.
Musk
Musks are not “musky” in the sense of a human body or animal smell. Modern musks are generally soft, clean, and powdery, often reminiscent of laundry or baby products. They can also lean woody or floral. Ambroxan is also frequently labeled a musk, despite smelling nothing like other musks—just like it doesn’t smell like amber. Because perfume marketers are assholes.
Balsamic
Warm, resinous, slightly sweet. Think sap, resins, vanilla. This overlaps with amber and incense.
Incense
Frankincense, smoke, patchouli—thick, rich, warm, and smoky. Think Catholic mass, a hippie yoga studio, or a shop that sells bongos and Hacky Sacks. But better.
Leather
Smells like leather. Shoes, boots, jackets, horse saddles. Literal but constructed from smoky, animalic, and synthetic materials rather than actual hide.
Aromatic
Herbal, sharp, dry. Think lavender, rosemary, sage, thyme. These are the scents massage therapists use in their homemade oils.
Chypre
A classic structure, not a single smell. Traditionally built around a citrus top (often bergamot), a floral heart, and a dark, mossy base—oakmoss, labdanum, patchouli. The result is sharp, dry, and elegant. But it’s another broad category and one chypre might smell nothing like another.
Know What You Like (and What You Hate)
Knowing what you like obviously helps. Look up the notes and elements of the scents you already enjoy on sites like Basenotes and Fragrantica. But understand what you’re looking at: note lists are not formulas or ingredient lists. They’re an attempt to describe how a perfume presents itself, not what it’s actually made of. If woody, patchouli, and balsamic show up again and again, you probably like the effect of those things. Not necessarily the materials themselves, and not in every context, but the general direction in which they push a perfume. Note that you will see a lot of the same elements repeated over and over again, like bergamot, amber, and musk. This is because these ingredient families are conceptually structural workhorses. They have a function, but they don’t necessarily define the scent.
And it’s all just ideas. Two perfumes can list the exact same notes and smell completely different.
Knowing what you hate is also probably helpful. I generally hate perfumes that smell like cupcakes and flowers mixed together. So, I’d probably stay away from anything called “Cupcake Flowers.” But that doesn’t mean I’m going to hate every floral gourmand, and open minds have more fun than closed ones.
Get to Know Perfumers
A useful exercise is to look up the perfumers behind the scents you already like, then see what else they’ve made. We have styles that show up in texture, balance, and structure, not just in note lists.
“Perfumers have signatures,” the perfumer Sophia Grojsman told the New York Times in 1993. “You can pick up a fragrance and know who the perfumer is by the way certain ingredients are put together. I’m known for floral accords, bottoms, and cleavage.”
Grojsman is the nose behind what the Grojsman Accord, aka the “hug me” accord (an accord is a blend of two or more fragrance materials combined to create a scent or scent idea), a minimalist structure made from four materials—Hedione, Iso E Super, Galaxolide, and methyl ionone gamma. It makes up the bulk of Lancome’s Trésor, released in 1990, and reminds me of the nineties as a whole; big, smooth, diffusive, and unmistakably of its time.
Another example is Jean Claude Ellena, former in-house perfumer for Hermes, whose signature style is minimalist fantasy. Ellena creates entire worlds with few ingredients, which is harder than it sounds, and is the nose behind one of my favorite scents of all time, First, by Van Cleef & Arpels.
Take this with a grain of salt, obviously. A perfumer who makes a broody woody incense can also turn around and betray you with a fruity floral gourmand.
More Suggestions for Choosing a Scent Online
Ask AI
You can also ask AI chatbots to suggest scents with similar profiles or note groupings to the ones you already enjoy. This works best as a way to come up with options you’d never think to look for yourself. It works poorly as a decision-maker. AI is very good at pattern matching and very bad at understanding how perfume actually wears. Like how scents with exactly the same listed notes can smell completely different. Also, AI is just wrong about a lot of stuff a lot of the time.
Order Decants
Another smart idea is to test through decanting companies like Surrender to Chance. They buy full bottles and sell samples and small sizes so you don’t have to drop hundreds of dollars on something you wind up hating. It’s brilliant. They don’t have everything, but they have a lot, and ordering a bunch and trying them all is super fun.
Try a Discovery Set
Discovery sets are another good option. Most perfume houses offer them. I have one featuring five of my signature scents, which I’m mentioning here because it would be weird not to. You’re bound to like one of them, right? And your mom/sister/husband/worst enemy might like another.
Ask Us!
You can also just ask the perfume house. You want to know what perfumers like to talk about most? PERFUME. Hoo boy, we could talk about that shit for hours, and there are not enough people to listen to us, which is why so many of us are on Reddit threads talking to other perfumers. It’s a very niche subject. So, when someone is like “Hey, can I ask you a question about perfume?” We’re like FUCK YEAH YOU CAN.
Think Friends with Benefits, Not Soulmate
Finally, don’t get stuck on the idea that you have to commit. I know people with signature scents—five of them wear Clinique Aromatics Elixir, which is such a classic, I can’t say enough good things about it—but I think the idea is mostly overrated. It’s like wearing one outfit every day.
Why pick just one thing when there are so many works of scent art out there? Perfume works better on rotation than as a lifelong commitment. We go through different moods, different seasons, different versions of ourselves. Liking a scent for a while and then moving on doesn’t mean it failed. It means things change, sometimes over years, sometimes by the hour.
To Recap Your Lesson on Buying Perfume Online
So that’s the method: learn the language, notice patterns, sample before committing, ask questions, don’t overinterpret notes, don’t expect certainty, buy smaller when possible. Repeat as needed.